Studio: Shaft
Director: Shin
Oonuma (Series Director); Akiyuki Shinbo (Director)
Screenplay: Kenichi
Kanemaki
Based on the manga by Hekiru Hikawa
Voice Cast: Chiwa
Saito as Rebecca "Becky" Miyamoto; Ai Nonaka as Ichijō-san; Fumiko
Orikasa as Himeko Katagiri; Kana Ueda as Kurumi Momose; Kayo Sakata as Sayaka
"Rokugo" Suzuki; Satsuki Yukino as Rei Tachibana; Yui Horie as Miyako
Uehara
Viewed in Japanese with English Subtitles
Pani Poni Dash was a title
I saw very early into my interest into anime in the 2000s – a strange period
with hindsight, now ADV Films, who
distributed this, no longer exist, and for some inexplicable reason we once
bought anime in three to four episodes per disc as separate releases for one
television series, this one such case in the day, without questioning the cost
of this. Available together through the likes of Crunchyroll in the streaming era, one of the biggest reasons I was
not a fan of this in the day was that I felt it was “too weird” back then and
too random. Neither helping is that, back then, it felt like the version of Azumanga Daioh (2002) you had back
home, which is mean to both shows, completely missing the point of both series.
Daioh is very different to this,
though one of the biggest flaws with this series still, whilst I have grow to
appreciate it considerably, is that if this had followed the high school
clichés more, I think this would have been a great show rather than a funny
one, which starts to deviate too much with its indulgences than use them to
parody that genre.
Starting with a Planet of the Apes parody, one of the
many parodies Western and Japanese you will see, we are introduced to Rebecca
Miyamoto, a Japanese-American prodigy who is able to become a high school
teacher at eleven years old, teaching Class 1C at Peach Moon Academy. There are
arguably too many characters, including the other classes, but to give you the
idea of who we have in Class 1C in their anime versions there is: Himeko
Katagiri, a hyper-active but lovable doofus whose cowlick is literally the
source of her energy as reveal early on; Ichijō, managing to top the weirdness
scale as a strange figure able to summon rain to willingly poisoning
classmates, even able to see the aliens spying on Rebecca from orbit; Miyako
Uehara, somewhat the geeky stereotype there to be annoyed and have a shiny
forehead; Rei Tachibana, the most mature if capable of being vindictive, the
glue to keep everyone together; Sayaka Suzuki (No. 6), who does suffer from a
lack of characterization if with a lovable charm; and Kurumi Momose, where the
joke is that she is the bland and normal one, giving her an existential crisis,
as well as introducing a legitimately funny running gag that, as a result, she
is the one who reacts to the increasingly insane events as most of us would,
with bafflement, until the point she begins to accept the screwed up logic of
the world. Then there is Mesousa, probably the most depressed rabbit in all of
media, even over the insanely twisted humour of Andy Riley’s The Book of
Bunny Suicides (2003) comic, in terms of the most depressed, put upon and
poorest bugger of the species in media, whose depression and lack of fingers
makes him hapless and lovable. Even before the cat in the school vending
machine, who claims to be literal God, starts to torment him, Mesousa is the
parody of cute animal sidekicks in dire need of a hug if Kurumi Momose was not
already hanging out with him in the school rabbit hutch depressed she was call
bland again. The aliens, as mentioned, are a Greek chorus, if accidentally
breaking the rule to not interfere with the earthlings a few times, studying
Rebecca as a subject and add their own amusement as a group too.
The show to its
credit does have a good gag for everyone, but there are a lot of characters
beyond this. Some of parodies of anime and manga, such as Behoimi, the magical
girl who has no actual powers, whilst others include a very clumsy girl, an
extravagant girl who brings exotic animals to class, the war between a film
club and drama club pair of girls where they do not know their real identities
and start to bond, and a few male characters, including the elderly teacher
which a foot in the morbid and occult. A personal favorite are two other girls
who are a double act, a shorter raven haired girl named Otome Akiyama who
clearly has a friendship with the other girl, the considerably taller Suzune
Shiratori who does have an affection for her, even if it means tormenting Otome
and trying to constantly use the pressure point on her head to keep her permanently
short. To say the show has a lot within it to accept is to realize by episode
three, when the cowlick Himeko has is shown as not only sentient but has
unnatural abilities, you also get a random Batman
Returns (1992) Cat Woman parody, and some twisted jokes like the student
ending the episode dead behind class 1C’s blackboard when trying to spy on
them. A camping episode early on reveals kappa, the mythological creatures of
Japan’s folklore, are experimenting in their own rocket space project in the
deepest Japanese woods. By episode thirteen of twenty six episodes, the first
of a few robot parodies appears, and by episode ten earlier, Behoimi and a
newly introduced character, a maid named Media who knows her from their
mysterious military pass, are disarming remote bombs around the school whilst
everyone goes through their school vacation projects. It is that kind of show.
One of the
hugest things about this show, and is one of its best virtues, is the
production value, which is not a surprise when this is a studio Shaft
production where, whilst he is not the series director, the director underneath
Shin Oonuma is Akiyuki Shinbo. Akiyuki
Shinbo, and Shaft in general, emphasize a distinct art style and
willingness to experiment, such as in Puella
Magi Madoka Magica (2011), and this is not different, a parody anime where
the production team were just allowed to indulge in their most experimental
side. The premise is blown up countless time and the fourth wall is constantly
mocked, with scenes shown to be on a stage being directed by a film crew.
Various visual gags transpire, such as “Punishment Pinball” in episode 7, or
RPG game parodies, which change the aesthetic considerably, as there is the use
of real images especially for food as collage. Even how to get around
painstaking depicting the whole class, replicating the same character models
over and over, is stylized and has moments when the production switch this up
with figures from fashion magazines with disturbing open smiles. Weird sight
gags, parodies or plain non- sequitur fill the screen, and you will see R. Lee Ermey in his Full Metal Jacket (1987) appearance
as a screenshot at random times for no reason, like how the show starts to get
more invested into parodying anime and manga the more episodes pass. It is not
obvious things either like a Neon Genesis Evangelion (1995), but ones which are
explicitly for the Japanese viewership or those who get the reference, such as
changing the characters’ designs to briefly match Shigeru Mizuki's GeGeGe no
Kitarō, or explicitly referring to the work in character design of Riyoko Ikeda.
Sadly they only start to appear near the end of the series, but some fo the
funniest, because you do not need to get the references to appreciate the
melodramatic clichés it is touching on, are all the elaborate excuses Himeko
has for being late to class, most of which are shoujo manga parodies. Even the
music is eclectic, with even yodeling bursting through the soundtrack at one
point, and deserves credit for its unpredictability.
The randomness
does need to be accepted – like the entire tangent about a lost Holed Pasta
Civilization which learnt the ability to make them from aliens, at least to how
Himeko views them, or how the aliens, when not causing problems or being
noticed even by Ichijō’s todder sister through their viewing telescope,
eventually start to look like the cast of Star
Trek: The Next Generation. Honestly the biggest issue with Pani Poni Dash
is eventually the school setting is just a location by the final episodes,
feeling like it is bored with the set-up and more concerned with the world
being threatened by an asteroid, an Edo period chambara parody, or Himeko being
possessed by a sentient space mushroom. The space mushroom is so strange it is
funny, but honestly, the show starts to get too indulgent and baggy by its last
episodes, when consistency would have been found more if this content was
forced onto high school anime clichés fully.
The Azumanga Daioh comparison is apt even
if entirely different comedies, where Daioh
took the time frame of school events, from sports day to the cultural
festival, and had moments of legitimately strangeness too to contrast its jokes
about things real teenagers would go through with school. Pani Poni Dash could have been the weirder parody, where an episode
mentioned early on, disarming bombs juxtaposed with the school vacation projects
being talked of in class, fully shows when this duality works perfectly. The
show is funny, visually creative, and I cannot have anything but admiration for
all the female voice actors here; comedies, especially ones this idiosyncratic,
where there is all the gags and vocal changes, even the idiosyncrasies of the
casts’ like Sayaka Suzuki calling everything the “most ---- of the year”,
provide Herculean vocal stretching to test anyone, and I admire the dexterity
of all the cast for ridiculous some of the scenes and moments get. The reason
as mentioned I was not a fan of this in the day was because this gets weird for
the sake of it, to the point it seems like the concept of being a high school
anime parody is a pretense. With time having past, how weird the series is was
not an issue in the slightest, even when I am lost, but that it could have
tried to force itself more onto its high school story premise becomes the lost
opportunity. There is a cultural festival episode, but not for example a sports
day one, and that feels like a lot of lost moments could have been done with
all the idiosyncratic characters and reoccurring gags this show does have,
leading to funnier moments.
Pani returned, abruptly in
a 2009 OVA, effectively a one-off new episode also by Shaft, which was clearly used to advertise the manga, still going
in from 2000 to 2011. It is obscure to the point I had no idea of its existence
until I had returned to the original series, not included with the original
work in streaming or a physical release in the West. Even the opening credits
are the same, and it feels like a run back in nice comfortable shoes for the
voice cast and the production team to a work they liked. Only some tame fan
service, mild titillation, suggest anything remotely different, alongside the
questionable decision to dress Rebecca, in an antagonist's role, in a tweens'
size Germanic black uniform, which we will just ignore as a poor choice. It
would have actually been a good episode in the source series, actually emphasizing
the better virtue of having normal school activities distorted in an absurd
touch, here how Rebecca's class and a couple others have failed exams but have
a chance to avoid retest if they can beat the school tradition of "Kick
the Can". This is an all day event where they have in a school day until
5pm, without all of them being caught by their persuaders, to kick the
aforementioned soda can. It definitely has jokes to remind you this is Pani Poni Dash, such as the aliens
returning with a parody of scenes of Robert
De Niro and Al Pacino,
represented in close parody caricature, from Michael Mann's Heat (1995),
but barring some of the more overt light eroticism, this has a lot more good
jokes, such as Media the maid and the magical girl, on the pursuers'' side,
wishing to protect the can by planting M18 landmines and military defense
weaponry around the school. It is the last piece to a work which, baring an
internet radio show and spin-off manga on specific characters, has a lot I
admired but was in the animated version a show which is flawed entirely because
the premise, whilst mad as a box of frogs in tone, has so much you can work
with that it is actually not as interesting to be as unpredictable as it was,
the punch lines missed of trying to pretend to be a cohesive high school comedy
with this motley crew of lovable school girls and miscreants tantalizing in
where it could have gone with that dynamic schism.