Director: Yoshimasa Hiraike
Screenplay: Yoshimasa Hiraike
Based on the videogame by Enterbrain
Voice Cast: Tomoaki Maeno as
Jun'ichi Tachibana; Shizuka Itou as Haruka Morishima; Rina Satou as Kaoru
Tanamachi; Hiromi Konno as Sae Nakata; Yukana as Ai Nanasaki; Ryoko Shintani as
Rihoko Sakurai; Kaori Nazuka as Tsukasa Ayatsuji; Kana Asumi as Miya Tachibana;
Takuma Terashima as Masayoshi Umehara; Risa Hayamizu as Maya Takahashi; Yū
Asakawa as Hibiki Tsukahara
Viewed in Japanese with English subtitles
I can't believe you tried to eat me.
In terms of premises, this
attempt to adapt a Playstation 2 era
light novel does take a distinct approach to the whole issue with that medium,
that many are designed around forking paths in the narrative based on one's
choices. Here, instead of merely one romantic comedy/drama over twenty four
episodes based around one figure our lead Jun'ichi Tachibana is attracted to,
you have six narrative arches over four episodes each, all based around one of
six female school students the male protagonist becomes romantically involved
with.
If anyone wants to raise concerns
immediately, than yes, whilst this show has surprisingly more nuisance than
most, it does have to struggle over its own structure being around choosing and
picking a perfect girlfriend, a concern as all the narratives do end positively
one way or another, from simple romance to even one leading to when the couple
married and had a daughter in the conclusion years later from high school. If
taken negatively, it is fetishistic unintentionally. Positively, it is a nice
touch of odd cosmic unpredictability that we can see six different worlds where
six women can cross the lead Jun'ichi's life. It is never addressed why the
structure exists, and baring the end episode preview for the next one, nor does
the show ever get self aware of this structure until the OVA episodes that came
after. Thankfully, whether the source material is wholesome or insidiously more
problematic than it looks, Amagami SS
is a show with a lot more heart than anything more duplicitous, especially in
mind there are worse works in existence in anime about multiple female love
interests.
Boiled down, each arch is about
one female classmate. Haruka Morishima begins Arch 1, the flighty and eccentric
popular girl. Kaoru Tanamachi, for Arch 2, Jun'ichi's tomboy best friend. Arch
3 is about Sae Nakata, a first year and friend of his youngest sister Miya, who
is timid and quietly spoken. Arch 4, about another first year and a friend of
Miya called Ai Nanasaki, at arm's reach in mood and standoffish. Arch 5 is
about Rihoko Sakurai, a childhood friend of Jun'ichi's, who is always concerned
about her weight, likes to eat, and is a very sweet person. Arch 6, the last,
is about the school head for the Christmas Founder's festival Tsukasa Ayatsuji,
which is apt as all these arches follow that Jun'ichi was spurned at Christmas
two years before each story on a date, and each story involves or concludes
around the Founders festival for Christmas, both leading to dramas for their
female characters but also his own anxieties about having his heart broken once
before.
Tonally, Amagami SS is a high school romantic comedy with some drama and a
bit of sex humour. It is the type of show that is prolific, and can be argued
as placating to fetishes of the perfect high school, as it is common in anime
and manga, to the point it is probably an uncomfortable testament to how
gruelling adult life in the work place is in Japanese culture. It is also the
kind of show anime criticism I listen to tends to warn people like myself
against, which lead me to being hesitant coming to this show despite being
intrigued by the premise. Thankfully, the show always stays on the side of
charming, helped for once by our male protagonist Jun'ichi having some actual
characterisation. From the extreme of a first person camera stand in who never
talks, any male protagonist remotely with personality would raising the bar to
the better, but here we have someone we can actually like. He is still the meek and polite male
stereotype, and girl crazed, but he shows virtue, shows a clear sense of
kindness that would lead him to being attractive to his female classmates, and
has little touches which help considerably build his personality, such as acrophobia,
a fear of heights, which is never a plot point but naturally comes up as it
would in real life in situations like going to a tall building with a glass
floor on a date. The only really exaggerated aspect about him, with his best
male friend Masayoshi Umehara, is that the pair trade "porn" between
each other, which is absurd especially when you realise they are treating
magazines with bikini models as precious contraband. To Amagami's credit, Jun'ichi is depicted as still being a horny
heterosexual male, but one with actual aspects to him which you can admire,
just happening to also been a young adult and thus in a time where romance is
still a confused experience.
Knowing the cast are mostly
between sixteen and seventeen, which is surprisingly older than I had presumed
for anime high school, you can see the case as being more mature in aspects,
but still having the prangs, hesitancies and concerns of being young adults.
Likewise the female cast is given time to grow, especially as even in other characters'
arch the other five female characters still appear in the stories. Fanservice
is there but thankfully minimal, the focus on romance and character
development. Personally, my heart sides with Kaoru Tanamachi being the real
narrative path as, alongside being the best arch, it did touch upon the fact
that, having a female best friend when I was a teenager, there is a chemistry
there even if you remain merely friends, something which is played upon in this
case when Kaoru as the female tomboy with Jun'ichi joshes and teases him. The
same can be said for Rihoko Sakurai as, showing what a sad sack I am, I am
naturally going to be more sympathetic to the character who is a childhood
friend who has hidden her crush for him, especially as her arch is more from
her perspective. Interestingly hers is the only with there not being any
romance, only the optimistic hope for one, set around her tea club instead.
Honestly, everyone in the female
cast, in the annuals of characterisations I have encountered, are a lot better
depicted here. Haruka Morishima is the only one I would not want dating the
lead as, whilst her arch as the first starts the series, the eccentric
Japanese-British student eventually, even if unintentionally, has a potential
gay reading which is so much more intriguing then a generic romance. This
flighty figure who skirts around school clubs and collecting images of cute
dogs is much more interesting when she (questionably) is spying on the female
swimming team, as she also finds them cute, or (more positively) in the
relationship with her best friend, the sane person to reprimand her
indulgences, whose relationship together yet is sweet and even involves in one
arch participating in a best couples competition which is meant for male and
female couples but they compete in for a lark. Even in terms of a character
like Tsukasa Ayatsuji, the last and in danger of being such a bland figure from
how she is only in the other arch the person getting the Christmas festival
ready, plays that off actually to an advantage as she is insanely complex with
many layers, to the point of even being very manipulative and dark just to
complete a noble act when she finally loses all her masks, even playfully
toying with the idea the show will turn into horror story for a joke.
Structurally as well, there being
two opening themes throughout the series, each narrative arch has a different
end credits and song, from the perspective of the female love interest and sung
by their voice actress. If ever Japanese anime evokes the old era of the
variety entertainer, it's in examples like this. The arches themselves do not
really differ from each other. Amagami
is paradoxically able to create feature films effectively with their four
episode stories, and have a leisured pace between them, story wise gentle with
any tension coming from seeing parts of the female lead's own personal lives
which affect them, never any drastic. Production wise, it is bright but
naturalistic in depiction, the characters not as exaggerated and in this world
none likely to have pink hair unless any dyed their locks or for a single scene
joke. The only real exception is for Sae Nakata. She is the character in most
danger of the show revealing its hand as a stereotypical "perfect
girlfriend" show. A freshman, meek and shy, she can easily be confused as
being a middle school student (i.e. younger), as it found when she wants to go
to a tokusatsu team performance for kids as she loves the show in question1,
but as a common running gag has a big bust even her female friends wish they
had.

It is a character, especially for
the last detail, you could roll your eyes at. The arch however decides to go
for a broader tone, noticeable in a male narrator you never hear outside this
arch, his melodramatic delivery deliberately adding to the more comedic tone of
the arch. He is also voiced by Jouji
Nakata, whose career in anime but also video games has allowed him to voice
a lot of bold, mighty voiced figures between M. Bison, Albet Wesker, Alucard
and Megatron among many, characters I have mentioned if you look into suggest
why his inclusion here is an inspired comedic touch. There is also the haunted
house sequence, when Junichi takes Sae to the amusement park, which is the
weirdest moment of the series and legitimately strange. Somehow this attraction
has been allowed access to a powerful hallucinatory gas, which alongside
creating creepy monsters in an ancient Egyptian pyramid setting, also leads to Sae
turning into a bowl of ramen, which gets kinky when Junichi cannot stop himself
from considering eating her. Yes, even I was caught off-guard that this
transpired.
In fact, whilst a quaint series
altogether which pulls away from lurid fanservice, it is amazing how Amagami SS get kinky a lot in
unexpected ways. Kissing a girl's belly button over an extended period of time,
kissing the back of another's knee, the obsession with swimming team uniforms,
a reminder that Japanese culture if merely viewed from a stereotype of being
very meek and polite forgets that eroticism can appear in unexpected places in
their pop culture quite a bit. For Ai Nanasaki's arch as well, it is just
explicit, romantically having them eventually taking a bath naked (to his
surprise) in a secret outdoor hot spring on land her family owns. I have to
admit, whilst the kinkiness of some of this series is odd, especially the bowl
of ramen scene, I am happy the show does not shy away from this as, whilst
nothing is consummated, it does deal with the likely tension of having someone
stay over you like and having to share the same bed as takes place. It also,
for all the aspects that are usual in anime, like someone accidentally seeing
something out of context or accidentally stumbling in on someone in the bath,
usually the lead's sister, the decision to not ogle its cast means that when it
does decide to be more sensual, it is in good taste for once.
The two OVA episodes, if you are
a completist, do end the show on a poor note. Thankfully, they are bonuses, two
regular length episodes, both offering tantalising attempts to cross all these
divergent paths but having points that undermine them. The first offers a
really interesting shift, actually radical in context, as it interconnects all
the beginnings of each romance, only to have a female admirer break up
potential relationships between the female cast and Junichi by bringing each
one to the same back alley at the school and lying that he has a girlfriend
already. It is still romanticising a stalker mind, and the problem with the two
OVAs is that they are one episode for two different stories. As a result, what
could have been a redeemable character, who is attracted to Junichi and becomes
romantically attached to him, is just left as a problematic figure even if the
end credits sequence is her actually apologising to everyone one set to music.
The last is about Junichi's
little sister and meat bun obsessive Miya, thankfully the show never turning
into an incestuous romance like a My
Sister, The Writer (2018), instead from the perspective of a regular character
trying to figure out why her older brother has no girlfriend yet, learning that
he is yet surprisingly popular among women as she (alongside the girl introduced
in the first OVA) secretly follow him on a day. It is in many ways a sweet
episode, the sister bonding with her older brother in the end. The problem with
the episode is that it does stumble badly into bad taste, namely not having
enough time to address her obsession that he has to have a girlfriend, less
like a natural concern but one implanted into her thoughts as necessary. There
is also a scene where she does wonder if he is gay - if this had been a four
episode arch, this scene where the two characters blunder into toe curling
defensiveness could have worked (even shot by shot and same dialogue) if he had
learnt from it and Miya especially grew up a lot during an arch. If she has to
accept her brother is his own person, then what could have started as a first
episode to an interesting, non-romantic arch would have been special. More so,
in a scene that would grow in a longer arch, that she even rejects interest
from a boy her own age smitten with her and thus has a bit of complexity to
work on.
Thankfully those OVAs are side
material, though any material which builds into a canon narrative sadly does shadow
the final result even if you can separate them, especially those bonus episodes
shoves the series' own foot in its mouth with questionable aspects, raising the
issue this series' premise always had of the "perfect girlfriend" to
the "perfect (i.e. bland) heterosexual couples" story regardless of
tact. Excluding them, than the show as it transpired is actually quite nice, because
really, beyond this, I enjoyed Amagami
SS a lot and am fond of it. A guilty pleasure? Partially, entirely because,
as mentioned, you cannot help but read ideals into the material that are an
issue even if accidental, a greater issue of there are a lot of anime (and
visual novels) about dating from a heterosexual male perspective, a lot of
which I will eventually also be getting to. There is also the existential concern,
which the premise accidentally raises, that you think of all the female characters
sympathetically as Junichi is dating someone else in another timeline. That definately
is unintentional; who would have thought that a romantic comedy anime would
offer the perils of omnipresence?
That in itself was why I found
the premise fascinating coming to the series, unconventional in content but one
of the unique premises in spite of the show never being unconventional or weird
in tone. The juxtaposition adds a distinction the more you think about it,
baring one scene with ramen tonally normal.
Usually a premise like this is a Groundhog Day scenario or Jorge Luis Borges' The
Garden of Forking Paths, the later a famous short story talking about parallel
realities and all the various forms of it.
Whilst one would usually hope for any show to tackle this existentially,
anime with a great record of accomplishment for exploring these ideas, for once
I am glad Amagami never went that
direction but instead played with it for fun. It was more concerned with being
the teller of the romantic stories, and it did so with a wink, as even the OVAs
for all my issues ended the show perfectly...the final episode preview being
for the first arch, creating an ouroboros.
================
1) At this point in my anime
viewing, I am now aware that these live "hero shows", for tokusatsu
programs, are more than likely common at Japanese theme parks and events. This
is not surprising and actually ridiculous for me to have only considered now
as, if you have live spectacle shows at Western theme parks, why wouldn't you
have similar ones for tokusatsu programming?