Studio: Toei Animation
Directors: Hidehiko Kadota and
Kouzou Nagayama (Tenshu Monogatari); Tetsuo Imazawa (Yotsuya Kaidan); Kenji
Nakamura (Bakeneko)
Screenplays: Yuuji Sakamoto
(Tenshu Monogatari); Chiaki J. Konaka (Yotsuya Kaidan); Michiko Yokote
(Bakeneko)
Tenshu Monogatari adapted from the drama by Kyōka Izumi; Yotsuya Kaidan adapted from the play by Nanboku Tsuruya IV
Voice Actors:
a) Tenshu Monogatari
Hikaru Midorikawa / Kirby Morrow as
Zushonosuke Himekawa; Houko Kuwashima / Willow Johnson as Tomi Hime; Saeko Chiba / Tracey Power as Oshizu; Yui Kano / Anna Cummer as Ominaeshi; Kappei
Yamaguchi / Alec Willows as Kaikaimaru; Masaya Onosaka / Samuel Vincent as Kikimaru
Yotsuya Kaidan
Hiroaki Hirata / Brian Dobson as
Iemon Tamiya; Mami Koyama / Nicole Oliver as Oiwa Tamiya; Yūko Nagashima / Rebecca Shoichet as Osode
Yotsuya; Keiichi Sonobe / Samuel Vincent as Gonbei Naosuke; Ryō Hirohashi /
Lalainia Lindbjerg as Oume Ito; Wataru Takagi / Michael Adamthwaite as Yomoshichi
Sato
Bake Neko
Takahiro Sakurai / Andrew Francis
as Kusuriuri the Medicine Seller; Yukana / Kelly Sheridan as Kayo; Tetsu Inada / Trevor Devall as Odajima; Chikao
Ohtsuka / Scott McNeil as Clan Lord Yoshiyuki; Naoki Tatsuta / Paul Dobson as Lord
Yoshikuni; Seiji Sasaki / John Novak as Lord Yoshiaki; Yōko Sōmi / Alison
Matthews as Lady Mizue; Kozue Kamada / Tabitha St. Germain as Lady Mao; Yuu
Shimaka / Ken Kramer as Katsuyama; Eiji Takemoto / Andrew Kavadas as Sasaoka; Yurika
Hino / Tabitha St. Germain as Miss Sato; Kiyonobu Suzuki / Trevor Devall as Yahei
Viewed in Japanese with English Subtitles
Commissioned for Fuji TV's Noitamina block, highly regarded for its artistically and
narratively different anime shows - where Masaaki
Yuasa's The Tatami Galaxy (2010) or
Princess Jellyfish (2010) came from -
Ayakashi: Samurai Horror Tales befits the slot early in its existence, as
it is three different horror tales between three to four episodes, of period
set folktales and yōkai I am fascinated by. Two of the three are adapting
classic authors for their tales too, adding to this an air of artistry, and
even when the Noitamina started over
the decades, from their 2005 inception to step away from a stereotypical young
male target audience, to have more action and pulpier productions, this was not
a bad thing either. This has led to shows like Samurai Flamenco (2013-14), and with well regarded productions like The Promised Neverland (2019-2020)
getting popular, the block can still claim respect for producing some of the
best and most interesting in animated television series. My interest in Samurai Horror Tales beyond just horror
anime would have been cemented by its connection to Mononoke (2007), another Noitamina
block member and one of the most unique looking series of any genre, having
been a spin-off from of the Ayakashi
stories itself not based on a classic tale.
The three tales are very straightforward
in what they are about, each taking very different directions to how to tell
them however. Depending on how you watch this, the Discotek Blu Ray release, released on October 29th 20191,
oddly has it that you can watch the second story's episodes, for Tenshu Monogatari, first before the
others, but the structure was set up for broadcast as Yotsuya Kaidan (four episodes), Tenshu Monogatari (four
episodes), and Bakeneko (three
episodes). Going by how I had watched this, Tenshu Monogatari as the first watched is a supernatural melodrama,
adapted from a drama by Kyōka Izumi. Izumi was a prolific novelist, dramatist
and writer, who I am aware of for Demon
Pond. It is a play even one of my favourite filmmakers Takashi Miike, in one of his many idiosyncratic leaps into any type
of filmmaking he has wanted to try, tried his hand at filming, in a very good
2005 theatrical production he recorded, based on a Keishi Nagatsuka re-adaptation of the source material. It is a work
too also adapted to cinema by Masahiro Shinoda
in 1979.
In Tenshu Monogatari, a
falconer named Zushonosuke, thanks to his evil feudal lord, has to retrieve a
prized falcon only to find a mansion of forgotten gods, housing all women who
as immortal beings, figures who succumb to hunger and consume the life force of
any mortals who wander there. One, Tomi Hime, starts to fall for him, which has
the issue that the more she is drawn to humanity, that will mean she loses her
immortality, which is sadly also infectious to everyone else there in the
mansion. The evil lord eventually catches wind of this, which leads to him
sending his soldiers to take the mansion by the final episode, a tragedy of
figures doomed to love each other despite them being different entities, or
that at home Zushonosuke has a fiancée named Oshizu who is naturally
heartbroken by all of this, becoming involved. This is the most conventional of
the three narratives, but as a bittersweet story, that in itself is a
curveball. It still has a ghoulish edge, and there is the fact that there are
two monsters as a comedy duo and Greek chorus, two thieves who only help Zushonosuke
out to steal from the mansion if they can.
%20a.jpg)
All the stories have their own
distinct looks. Also of note is that, throughout the series, they have their
own opening credits, with their own visual motifs and designs, even if they all
have the same opening theme song. It is probably the least expected in such a
context, HEAT ISLAND by Rhymester, a hip hop song with backing
by a koto, a traditional Japanese string instrument, which is as strange as
that songs but is yet an inspired choice, befitting a production which is
idiosyncratic. It befits how, whilst Tenshu
Monogatari is a very emotional drama at its heart, even the traditional
ghost story, Yotsuya Kaidan, is not
conventionally told at all, all the narratives here standing out with their
idiosyncrasies. All the stories have their own authors, Tenshu Monogatari's Yuuji
Sakamoto, who only has that one
credit in their career strangely, Michiko
Yokote for Bakeneko someone we
will get to for that story later in the review, and a figure I know very well
for Yotsuya Kaidan, Chiaki J. Konaka.
Konaka, someone I admired for his work, sadly has to be taken now
by me as a fan with a pinch of salt in recent years. A divisive screenwriter
for how obtuse he could be, from Serial
Experiments Lain (1998) to one of the strangest narrative arches of Mononoke itself, I admire how esoteric
and experimental his work is, even when, such as a live action film like Evil Dead Trap 2 (1992), figuring out
what is transpiring and in what reality can be lost entirely even on multiple
viewings. For a live reading of a script for Digimon Tamers, a follow
up to the show that many of us (including myself) saw episodes of as a kid, he
had a villain, which took on the form of "Political Correctness,"
that threatens the real and digital worlds, and had a special attack called "Cancel
Culture"1. Thankfully nothing from this raised concerns of far
greater and more problematic ideas he has had, but at a time where his own
personal blog expressed questioning views on COVID-19's reporting in worldwide
news2, sadly it did paint a picture for me of someone undermining
himself when, if brutal to say, his work in screenwriting usually, even if
frustrated viewers, was a lot more nuanced even with some of his hardest the
grasp scripts in anime storytelling. When watching Yotsuya Kaidan even this
came up here, as this is a really meta and clever retelling of the titular
tale, which feels alien in comparison, originally written as a kabuki play by Tsuruya Nanboku IV, as Tōkaidō
Yotsiya Kaidan, which becomes a story in itself as this version tells.
Nanboku himself is the narrator, and the play itself, as much as a
new retelling here, is the subject. The story itself is about a woman Oiwa who,
when her husband, Iemon Tamiya, is complicit in a poison she is given, which
disfigures half of her face, and the disposal of her body after her death,
taking revenge on him from the grave Iemon Tamiya is already established as a
unscrupulous rōnin, who even killed Oiwa's father, pretending bandits had done
so, to win her hand in marraige, before another woman wished him for her own
and concocted the plan to disfigure and disgrace her. This is a morbid
melodrama, where there is also her sister-in-law, lied to in a deceit by
another man who kills her suitor and pretends bandits also did it, and the
story takes on additional angst and wrought drama with its betrayals, seductions
and heartbreaks. Konaka's take goes
further in how the finale becomes Kaidan's
lasting legacy, Tsuruya Nanboku IV revealed
to have passed his mortal form and existing in an afterlife on the Earth,
considering his story and how it has lasted in Japanese popular culture, even
developing a curse around the plan where people adapting it have been maimed or
even killed. Were it not for a certain tale coming afterwards which is clearly
the gem of this entire anthology, I would hold this as a perfect piece in
itself worth seeing. All three are, and Yotsuya
Kaidan does feel like a perfect retelling of folklore in dissecting the
text, something also for me to show Chiaki
J. Konaka as a talented writer even if the real man stumbles in some bad
ideas too in his thought process.
%20b.jpg)
However it was Bakeneko which became a spin-off show
in itself own right, and alongside that spin-off Mononoke, no anime looks and feels tonally like this these stories
about a mysterious "Medicine Seller" at all. Bakeneko, alongside its
distinct art style and character designs by Takashi
Hashimoto, looks like it was illustrated on glossy waxed paper, done with
digital animation as I aware of with Mononoke,
but absolutely distinct in its composition. It is a horror story which yet uses
bright colours, has a precise use of environment design (patterns,
illustrations, even setting out locations), and where, clearly indebted to art
styles from Japanese history, such as Japanese woodblock prints, it brings it
into the modern era as a digitally animated production in movement. Even in
mind that the series got Yoshitaka Amano
to do the original character designs for Yotsuya
Kaidan, and have his illustrations on the opening credits for that tale,
one of the most iconic designers in anime and light novels who an acclaimed
artist outside of the mediums, Bakeneko
is an artistic masterpiece just in appearance, even in mind that this is a
prototype to what became Mononoke
the series.
It is also, with fair warning, a
bleaker narrative than Mononoke
could get, bearing in mind that the later series tackled heavy subjects, its
first arch surrounding the ghosts of aborted foetuses of brothel workers. It
says a lot in context however that Bakeneko
manages to have the bleakest narrative of this world, introducing us here to
the Medicine Seller, a figure here and in the later series whose job is exorcise
demons, a magic sword on his person (alongside other tools) which can only be
open when three criteria explaining the entity's existence come to light. A
bride is killed on her wedding day in a proud samurai clan, and whilst
suspicion comes on him, the Medicine Seller is quickly the only person able to
deal with the problem, the Bekeneko. This is a "goblin cat", cats of
supernatural form in Japanese mythology which are not necessarily as extreme as
this, a monster claiming vengeance, but symbolically meaningful here with the
context. This story will be uncomfortable for some, so fair warning is
recommended, as this is the case as was in Mononoke
that, as the truth and cause of the demon is revealed, it involves showing up the
wrongs of human beings, alongside this explicitly dealing with how people lie,
forget details or view it in a different perspective. Michiko Yokote was the screenwriter for this story, and whilst
multiple writers all contributed good work to Mononoke, Chiaki J. Konaka,
this is a great time, with the virtues she shows here, to praise Yokote. She is not someone I have
frequently encountered, but I am aware of her, whilst not the only screenwriting
contributor, for series composition, the person putting everything narratively
together, for Princess Tutu (2002-3),
an exceptional and unique fantasy tale about around ballet and fairy tales
that, again with Konaka getting briefly
involved, was a meta-text on fairy tales which was also a beautiful gem. Here,
dealing with an incredibly umcomfortable subject exceptionally at the heart of
this tale, the only not adapted from another source, I see another example of
her talent.
And that is true as a warning for
anyone interest. [Major Spoiler Warning]
The cause of the bekeneko here is that the samurai patriarch kidnapped a
woman, kept her in a cage as a sexual object, a peasant girl who was raped,
beaten and left to starve to death, which is as grim a narrative reveal, too
real for some, to consider. [Major
Spoiler Warning]. All three tales to their virtue, but especially Bekeneko, show why I came to love these
type of horror anime about folklore and figures like the Medicine Seller,
stepping in to resolve supernatural entities, as they become morality tales and
dramas with one-off characters, examinations of human beings which the Bekeneko pulls no punches in. Among
them, for its artistic innovations, and how impactful the narrative in its
centre is, clearly Bakeneko is the masterpiece
of the entire set, though it is to the credit of the three tales altogether
that they all succeed.
====
1) Discotek Media's announcement of Ayakashi:
Samurai Horror Tales, dated on Facebook
on August 13th 2019.
2) Digimon
Tamers Writer Chiaki J. Konaka Responds to Overseas Backlash Over 20th
Anniversary Stage Play, written by Kim
Morrissy for Anime News Network,
dated August 9th 2021.